You Can Choose Your Diet, But Criticism Isn’t Necessary
Written on
Understanding Food Choices
In this piece, I want to clarify that I do not consume meat. However, I also do not believe in punishing those who do, akin to the fictional "chokey" from Roald Dahl's Matilda, where misbehaved children face confinement. We live in a world that offers choices, albeit with varying degrees of freedom for different individuals.
It's essential to note that my intention is not to criticize any specific diet or individual. Negative commentary around dietary choices isn't constructive and doesn't foster growth. After all, no one enjoys the idea of being confined for their preferences.
Yes, it’s vital for all of us to reflect on our choices, but harsh criticism is not the answer. Such critiques often delve into a person's background, upbringing, and self-identity, as food is deeply intertwined with our cultural roots. Discussing our food choices is necessary; if we avoid the conversation, we risk stagnation.
I follow several vegan chefs on social media who showcase their creativity and delicious recipes made from whole foods. I find inspiration in their work and often seek new vegan ideas. Unfortunately, not everyone engages with these accounts for positive reasons. Some individuals use these platforms to voice their opposition, as if this were a competition rather than a personal choice.
While admiring a delectable crispy tofu burger, I encountered a dismissive comment: "Or you could just eat meat, instead of this fake meat." My instinctive response was that perhaps that person should remain silent and allow others to enjoy their preferences. I chose not to engage in the comment section, as I prefer to avoid online disputes, but the thought lingered.
To be fair, perhaps the commenter wasn’t attempting to be hurtful. They might genuinely believe that a meat-based diet is indispensable for health and taste. These situations could serve as chances for meaningful dialogue, but often, such discussions are lacking.
Exploring the Roots of Dietary Criticism
So, what drives people to critique others' food choices? The answer is layered, much like a complex cake. What we’ve been taught isn’t always grounded in truth, such as the notion that consuming oranges and milk together is harmful, or that swimming right after eating can lead to drowning.
There exists a plethora of cultural myths surrounding food, likely stemming from well-intentioned individuals. However, many of these beliefs lack scientific backing, especially regarding the debate between animal and plant-based diets.
For instance, in Portugal, my home country, we predominantly follow a Mediterranean diet, rich in local fish and meats, alongside various vegetables. When I decided to eliminate meat from my diet, my family’s primary concern was my protein intake.
This preoccupation with protein is not unique to Portugal; it’s a universal narrative that often elicits humor. Despite our modern, sedentary lifestyles, many believe that without ample meat, they will lose strength. This notion is particularly prevalent among men, as my mother often expressed that boys required meat to feel full and strong.
Interestingly, my boyfriend maintains a vegan diet yet remains quite fit and strong. This challenges the belief that meat is the only source of essential protein.
I delved into the cultural reasoning behind this widespread belief in protein deficiency linked to meat consumption. The idea of the "hunter-gatherer" lifestyle suggests that meat was once vital for strength in hunting, a task often associated with men.
However, scientific studies reveal that while humans are classified as omnivores, our anatomical and physiological traits are more aligned with herbivores, indicating a natural inclination towards plant-based diets.
Cultural ideals significantly influence our perceptions of strength, often associating it with traits deemed masculine, like emotional toughness and assertiveness. Some studies even indicate that men who identify strongly with traditional masculinity tend to prefer meat.
The existence of cultures such as the Rastafari Ital movement and the over 400 million vegetarians in India serves as a testament that one can thrive without animal products.
Ultimately, like any dietary practice, mindless eating can lead to nutritional deficiencies. There is no singular way to eat healthily. If we dismantled every cultural belief about food, we would find ourselves in an endless cycle of debate.
While cultural identity is crucial, it shouldn’t serve as an excuse to cling to outdated practices that no longer benefit us. It’s easy to adopt an 'us vs. them' mindset regarding meat consumption, but the reality is we share this planet. Our dietary choices carry weight, and we must recognize our individual responsibilities.
Natural selection compels us to adapt, and the Earth operates in cycles we cannot ignore. Clinging to old cultural ideals while disregarding current realities will not serve us. Our diets significantly impact the environment, a fact supported by extensive research. Ignoring this truth equates to willful ignorance.
It’s our collective duty to be aware of our choices and their implications, as we all contribute to the larger problem. Even those who follow a vegan lifestyle play a role in this consumer-driven cycle. We have the freedom to decide how much we contribute to this issue.
Perfection isn’t the goal, nor can we single-handedly reverse environmental harm. The world will continue on, regardless of our presence. However, our attitude towards conservation and respect for our planet will determine its future viability.
This dilemma transcends cultural or personal preferences; it’s a global concern. You can still savor your favorite comfort foods, but consider adapting your ingredients for sustainability.
Your grandmother likely didn’t always serve expensive cuts of meat; she utilized what was accessible and infused her meals with love. This is what truly makes food special—the care put into preparing local ingredients.
Ultimately, the memories we cherish and the ideals we uphold can be illusions. Humanity's strength lies in our ability to adapt and grow. Online trolling may provoke reactions, but it rarely leads to meaningful change, and lasting transformation is what we truly need.
Do you have an intercultural experience or story to share? Join the conversation at A-Culturated and become part of our community!