Chapter 1: The Current Landscape of US-China Relations

The global focus should be on China's international relations. Recent elections in Taiwan have been pivotal for China-US dynamics, alongside other international factors like China's Belt and Road Initiative (BRI). From a geopolitical standpoint, the US has been biding its time to assert itself in maritime territories, with recent incidents in the Red Sea providing an ideal opportunity.

The US aims to craft a maritime strategy centered around a concept known as alliance networking. This aligns with the broader Indo-Pacific strategy, which seeks to bolster defense and security collaborations aimed at countering China's ascent in the Pacific and Indian Oceans. This approach also aims to mitigate China's conduct in the South China Sea disputes.

The theory of China's rise has shifted predominantly towards viewing it as a threat in many Western academic circles. How did this perspective evolve in the West?

An insightful op-ed by Dewardric L. McNeal, the Founder and Managing Director of Longview Global, sheds light on this issue. Longview Global offers strategic consulting to help companies navigate geopolitical tensions.

In the current climate, this guidance is crucial as the US-China relationship becomes increasingly complicated, while the European Union grapples with the ongoing Russia-Ukraine conflict just beyond NATO's borders. Below is McNeal's op-ed discussing Apple CEO Tim Cook's recent trip to China, featuring an interview with CNBC.

Now, let’s delve into my reflections on the article.

“For years, the approach was clear: engage respectfully and commit to significant investments in China, hoping to unlock access to its vast markets and manufacturing capabilities.”

Tim Cook's recent visit to China, which included commitments to boost investments and expand research and development centers, illustrates this established strategy. His portrayal of China as 'essential' to Apple, along with his praise for the nation’s advanced manufacturing capabilities, encapsulates the essence of this engagement model.

This strategy has proven successful for Apple, the world's leading consumer technology company. Naturally, Apple will continue to affirm its strong presence in China, as it serves as the central hub for Industry 4.0 investments—often referred to as the Fourth Industrial Revolution. This era emphasizes advanced manufacturing, focusing on technological innovation rather than traditional labor and management structures.

Despite calls from many in the US to end the 'Made in China' era, it's evident that manufacturing in China is evolving under Industry 4.0. The potential for substantial growth is immense, as companies strive to enhance profits and deliver returns to shareholders, which this new industrial paradigm enables while drastically reducing global operational and labor costs.

“It can be argued that the turning point came long ago, marked by Google’s notable withdrawal from China in 2010, despite previous attempts at engagement by its leadership. The difficulties Google faced highlight the intricate nature of operating in China’s stringent regulatory environment, regardless of high-level diplomatic efforts.”

The example of Facebook is particularly telling. Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg made extensive efforts to appeal to China, showcasing his commitment to understanding Chinese culture and business practices by learning Mandarin and using it during his public engagements in China.

McNeal references these cases to illustrate why long-term investment in China may no longer be ideal for tech companies. However, it’s important to note that Google and Facebook do not share the same operational model as Apple. Apple depends on a just-in-time manufacturing strategy that relies on a cost-effective, efficient supply chain stretching across China and other parts of the Asia-Pacific region, particularly Taiwan.

Where else could Apple source microchips and lithium-ion batteries? For a company like Apple, the entire region is crucial. Unlike Google and Facebook, which don't manufacture consumer tech products—despite Meta's attempts to enter this market through AR/VR ventures—Apple's position as a leader in advanced manufacturing is secured by its partnership with China, which boasts a skilled labor force, efficient supply chains, and proximity to Japan, South Korea, and Vietnam.

“Aligning strategically with China's market and technological goals can entangle companies in the escalating trade and technology conflicts between the US and China. This battleground, characterized by efforts to control emerging technologies with potential military applications, creates a precarious landscape for businesses caught between nationalistic ambitions and their global market goals.”

I concur with this assessment. However, this reality was notably highlighted during the infamous trade war initiated by China's President Xi Jinping and former US President Donald Trump in 2018. While in Shanghai during that period, I observed no decline in foot traffic at local Apple stores. With numerous malls in Shanghai hosting Apple outlets, they were consistently bustling with shoppers eager for the latest iPhone.

My perspective shifted during a visit to Beijing in 2019. Having spent several years in Shanghai, I initially thought Apple reigned supreme in the Chinese market. However, the atmosphere in Beijing was markedly different. People were surprisingly attentive to my non-Apple phone, a Hisense model that I proudly owned due to its affordability. I quickly realized that local companies like Baidu had a more substantial presence in the city. It appeared that the trade war resonated more deeply in Beijing than in Shanghai.

As for the CEOs, they were not found in Beijing, where they should have been, but rather in Hainan, an island near the South China Sea. This underscores a broader issue: many executives remain unaware of the sentiments in Beijing, as they focus their attention on tech hubs like Shenzhen, Shanghai, and Hangzhou, neglecting the political landscape in China's capital, which will ultimately shape future economic policies, irrespective of the flourishing tech centers.

Chapter 2: Apple's Strategic Decisions and Geopolitical Dynamics

Discover how to secure a free Apple replacement by saying these three words.

Explore Apple's competitive strategies against Chromebooks during their latest event.